Judge says that young people "use roads as their own private clues" as a teenager arrested for driving without care, causing the death of a girl (16)


Accident Scene e (insert) Katie Murphy
Accident Scene e (insert) Katie Murphy

A JUDGE has imprisoned a teenage driver for driving recklessly causing the death of a 16-year-old girl when he warned that some Irish drivers, particularly young men, were dealing with public roads like their own race tracks.

Judge Eugene O & # 39; Kelly convicted Edward O & Shea (19) for 14 months after he noticed that the victim, Kate & Katie & # 39; Murphy (16) had sent a Snapchat video to a friend just seconds before the fatal collision in Waterford. they said they were: "He's probably going to die in the car."

An unidentified male voice replies, "Yes, probably."

A female voice then remarked, "Cheeky – bypassing the speed limit."

Katie Murphy

Katie Murphy

An unidentified voice answered, "Cheeky – going twice over the speed limit."

A Waterford Criminal Court jury did not show the social media videos during the trial because they were found to be violators of the rumor rule.

Judge O & # 39; Kelly said Ireland now needs to review such evidence in real-time social media video in the context of the trial.

In the O & # 39; Shea prison, he said careless driving was at the upper limit of the scale.

He also said that "he believes" O & Shea, an apprentice driver, could handle a car as powerful as yours.

"Some riders, especially the young ones, treat the roads as if they were their own racetracks and do so without any regard for the potentially catastrophic consequences for other road users and indeed for themselves," he said.

The parents of Katie Murphy, Vivienne and Hilary (far right) and their brother, Scot, outside the Criminal Court of Waterford. Photo: Ralph Riegel

The parents of Katie Murphy, Vivienne and Hilary (far right) and their brother, Scot, outside the Criminal Court of Waterford. Photo: Ralph Riegel

Judge O & # 39; Kelly noted that the so-called Clancy Amendment on the unaccompanied drivers of the student could not apply because the Tramore collision occurred before being passed in law.

However, he noted how O & Shea was driving a powerful and modified unattended Japanese car.

"Driving is not only illegal, it's dangerous."

The heartbroken Murphy family claimed to have lost their only child in the fatal traffic accident because O & # 39; Shea, driving unattended under apprentice license, lost control of a mighty modified Japanese car as she showed off to her friends.

Edward O 'Shea, now 19, was arrested for 14 months after being convicted before the Waterford Criminal Court for driving recklessly, causing death and negligent driving, causing serious injury.

He was acquitted by the jury in February of a dangerous direction leading to his death.

Katie Murphy of Ballinamona Co Waterford who died in a road accident in Tramore on 5.10.16

Katie Murphy of Ballinamona Co Waterford who died in a road accident in Tramore on 5.10.16

Kate & Katie & # 39; Murphy (16) died when the Japanese car with a specially lowered suspension being driven by O & Shea, went out of control and collided sideways with a wall outside a condo in Tramore on October 5, 2016.

The car also had low-profile tires and a side skirt.

The area of ​​the accident was covered by a speed limit of 50 km / h, but as there were no brake marks, it was impossible for Gardaí to determine how fast Toyota was traveling.

Forensic experts could only determine that the car finally hit a stone wall while traveling at about 32 km / h.

However, locals noticed the sound of a car traveling at high speed that day along the winding Cliff Road.

A woman was so alarmed by the sound that came from the armchair in her house to investigate – and seconds later she heard the sound of the impact.

Two other teenage car occupants, Joseph Walsh and Jessica Fynn, suffered terrible head and chest injuries in the accident at Cliff Road, Newtown, just outside Tramore.

Murphy's troubled parents, Hilary and Vivienne, said their lives were devastated by the loss of their only daughter in an accident that they insisted was totally preventable and due to O & # 39; Shea's carelessness.

The imported Japanese car, with a two-camera engine and a specially lowered suspension, was registered in the garage of Edward O's Shea's family, run by his father, Michael, and he was driving under a garage insurance policy in that day.

Judge O & # 39; Kelly noted the fact.

"It was extraordinary and blatantly irresponsible for the O & # 39; Shea Garage business to facilitate the driving of such a car (by a young apprentice driver)," said Judge O & # 39; Kelly.

Katie's father said they were convinced about what happened.

"In my opinion, we lost our daughter because Mr. O Shea was exhibiting a high-powered car," Murphy said.

Father Tramore described Edward O & Shea as "a very cold-hearted person," who had not spoken to his family, sent a letter, card or flowers about his daughter's death.

"He destroyed our lives."

Murphy urged Judge Eugene O & # 39; Kelly not to adopt a "soft touch" approach to the sentence and to seize the opportunity to send a deterrent message to other Irish users.

Mrs. Murphy said the tragedy was the worst nightmare of all parents.

"Your death is my past, my gift and my future," she sobbed.

"The selfish and careless actions of Edward O & Shea took my only daughter.

"The door to Katie's bedroom (in our house) is my biggest nightmare. She has hope, but there is no hope of being found."

Ms. Murphy said people are now afraid to look at themselves and their husbands so they will not see "the worst nightmare of every parent."

Murphy said they launched a traffic safety campaign in memory of their daughter – and asked the young people concerned about the speed of the driver who have the courage to demand the exit of the vehicle.

Shea, who appeared in court wearing black pants and a navy shirt and tie, sat upside down as the victim's impact statements were delivered by the parents of Katie Murphy and her brother, Scot.

The defendant, in a letter delivered to Judge O & # 39; Kelly, apologized for what his careless actions behind the wheel that day inflicted on three families.

"If I could change what happened, believe me, I would change everything," he said.

The court heard that O & Shea now suffers from the survivor's guilt, depression, anxiety, and post-traumatic stress disorder about what happened.

He has served a counselor for more than two years and has been subjected to the conviction of social media about what happened.

"I hope one day you (the Murphy family) can forgive me, but I want you to know that I'm really sorry.

"So many people were affected by my bad judgment that day."

Joseph Walsh's parents, John and Phil Walsh, delivered a letter in which they said they had no ill will toward the driver of the car.

The Shea was found innocent by a jury of the Waterford Criminal Court last month for dangerous driving, causing death and serious injuries.

He had offered a reckless driving request, causing death and serious injury before the trial began.

Shea, an apprentice mechanic, was 17 at the time of the tragedy, but now she's 19 years old.

He was driving on a provisional license for only five months when the tragedy occurred.

Ms Murphy, of Castlewoods, Ballinamona, Waterford was a passenger of the back seat of the car together with her friend, Jessica Flynn.

The Shea, of Magnh, Fenor, Waterford was convicted of driving recklessly, causing death and undue direction, causing injuries.

He was disqualified from driving for six years and fined 800 euros.

Online Publishers


Source link