Given that 2017 Star Wars Battlefront II is widely considered the turning point in an anti-sack talk that recently led to a looting law in the United States Senate, you may be forgiven for thinking that the games at Eletronic Arts have cash drawers.
Not so, says his vice president of legal and governmental affairs; they simply have "surprise mechanics". And they are "fairly ethical". Ufa!
EA's Kerry Hopkins made the comments as part of an oral testing session with the UK Parliament's Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Commission today (via PCGamesN).
MP of the Scottish National Party Brendan O 'Hara said the evidence suggests a "close" connection between cash and gambling, especially among teenagers. He then asked Hopkins, as well as a representative of Epic Games, who was also present to talk about Fortnite, if they considered the service boxes as an "ethical" feature.
"We do not call them service boxes," Hopkins began his response, adding that EA referred to them as "surprise mechanics."
She then worked out what exactly that means and why the so-called "mechanisms of surprise" are like blind toys. "If you go – I do not know what your version of Target is – a store that sells lots of toys and does a search for surprise toys, what you will discover is that this is something that people like. They like surprises.
And that's something that's been part of the toys for years, be it Kinder Eggs, Hatchimals or LOL Surprise. We think of the way we implement these types of mechanics in FIFA-[which] of course it is our great, our FIFA Ultimate Team and our packages – in fact, it's quite ethical and fun. Nice to people. "
She also said that EA does not consider service crates – sorry, "mechanical surprise" – to be playing, and "we also disagree that there is evidence to show that this leads to the game." However, this evidence has been sufficient for countries such as Belgium and The Netherlands, both of which have banned certain types of cash withdrawals randomized under their gambling laws.
Hopkins said that these decisions were rooted in the laws of each country, and EA also disagrees with them, although it has made the necessary changes in those regions to comply with its laws.
The rest of the session proceeded at a rapid pace, with government officials asking questions about how games work and trying to corner representatives from game companies confessing guilt to people selling real-money game items through third-party sites – which is clear very against the terms of service of these companies. Hopkins repeatedly dismissed these issues as "bad guys" actions and said that these bad actors, not the way the service boxes and adjacent systems are currently designed, are the problem.
"The packages, the surprise, this is fun for people," she said. "They like to win packages, open packages, build teams, change teams."
What is approaching is to inadvertently approach the real problem: the compulsiveness of the larger systems and the clear intentionality of their design. They are built on finely calibrated chance systems. Everything from the underlying statistics to the way to open them seems built to maximize the anticipation of Christmas.
As KotakuActress Heather Alexandra has published an article chronicling her own experiences with serving boxes: "Moment by moment, serve boxes are designed to capture attention with a mix of spectacle and psychological tricks different from what you might find on a hunting machine -nicks. "
In an update earlier this year, Epic removed the random element of purchase pillage boxes in FortniteIt is not royale mode of battle, save the world. During today's session, a company representative admitted that "there is more that the industry can do." EA, however, stands firm.
"I do not think we can agree to say games are addictive," Hopkins said. "I would say that Electronic Arts is already a very responsible company."
NSW And Victoria Push For Loyalty Boxes To Be Classified
With just under a month until the Senate's inquiry into "micro-transactions of games for items based on chance" -boxes and such-reports, more submissions for the inquiry were made public. Two of these submissions came from the Victorian Minister for Game and Beverage Regulation as well as the NSW Government Deputy Secretary for Drinks, Games and Racing, and both proposals are encouraging an update of rating guidelines to recognize service boxes.
See More Information